Photo by Photo Yaroslav Shuraev on Pexels
Writer: Craig Meerkamper
Let’s play a quick game. There are no wrong answers, only more information and more complexity. I’ll present you with a list of choices followed by some sentences of added context. Before reading each section of context consider at what point you’d be comfortable not reading any further and making a definitive decision with the limited information. Let’s get started.
The Game: Buying Your First Electric Car
After each paragraph you can:
A) Repair your current car to pristine condition.
B) Buy a new electric car.
C) Buy a used electric car.
D) Continue reading.
Your “ol’ reliable” has finally kicked the bucket with an impressive 300,000 km on the odometer. It was your first car out of university and took you everywhere, but it recently began making ‘the noise’ again and seeing that flashing yellow symbol on the dashboard probably shouldn’t have become the norm. You have many great memories with the car and suspect investing in some repairs could keep it going for another ten years.
---
You’re in a stable spot financially but you can’t help but mull over how much gas was burned over all those kilometers. Everyone seems to be getting a new car anyways but as a future minded person you want to feel like you’re doing SOMETHING to offset those record-breaking temperatures. You’ve heard that buying a new electric car is a good option, but you’ve also heard that the carbon produced from the construction alone would take decades to truly drive off.
---
While a new electric car sounds good a used one would mean that the carbon offset would be a bit easier to achieve since a brand-new car doesn’t have to be manufactured for you. Your current car’s resale value is basically just scrap anyways. There’s an electric car dealership that’s just opened near to you and you remember reading they’ve announced a ‘grand opening deal’ to the first 100 people that order a car from them.
---
While looking into used electric cars online you come across the same model listed for $40,000. You message the seller, but it takes a few messages for them to respond to you. They ask if you are willing to pay for the car in cash because they live about an hour's drive away from you. They don’t have much social media presence but do have generally good reviews on the other things they’ve sold before. Your old car is really starting to struggle now and making noises you can only describe as “expensive”. Calling the dealership about the deal you also learn that it was only on the first 100 pre-sales of the newest model which have already sold out.
---
The used seller has stopped responding to you online and appears to have deleted their account and all their listings. A recent media story has broken about the CEO of the electric car company making some comments about gay people’s right to marry and if it’s “necessary to legally enshrine those rights”. Your wife is highly displeased with their statements and is strongly against you buying any of their cars. You are also offput by the CEO’s statements because you are also a woman.
So, did you make your decision?
This game was inspired by something I heard Canadian marketing professor Gad Saad recently discuss. In a podcast segment discussing ‘Stopping Strategies’ he asks, “When is it that a person has acquired enough information to stop and make a choice?”
Sadd explains that “Every decision that we make every day; we don’t sample all of the relevant and available information before we make a choice. We sample until we have sufficiently differentiated between the choices that you can say ‘There’s no point in sampling more information, I now have enough information to vote for Trump’”.
Now regardless of whether you find his concluding example... compelling ... finding your decision threshold is important. When have we reached our own thresholds to make a conclusive decision and to take a stance that we will stand by? Be they in a professional context or our own personal beliefs, our thresholds are typically invoked faster than we’re even aware they’re there. Basic things like deciding what to have for lunch or when to go for a break, to decisions with more gravity like purchasing a house or committing to a business plan. In all cases we eventually have to take the leap and commit to a choice.
For myself, different decisions have different ‘decision thresholds’ largely depending on their level of impact, things like weighing their repercussions or consequences. Considering their permanence can also weigh heavily on me, because there’s comfort in the ability to retry or undo things if they don’t work out in our favor. Our thresholds are a largely personal metric that fluctuates from person to person.
The game you played took some inspiration from my childhood fascination with choose-your-own ending books (notably Goosebumps: Deep in the Jungle of Doom which can’t possibly hold up to my memories of it). This was a little game to test your own stopping points. There were no wrong answers with your decisions, only things to recognize about your process of decision rationalization. Did you have a gut instinct just by seeing the initial options? Was it a practical, social, or economic element that swung you one way or the other? Did your decision change with the more context you read through?
While you’re in this mindset I’d also highly recommend you check out Welcome To Vanguard Estates a phenomenal choose-your-own adventure I came across at university where you navigate the ethical decisions of putting your aging father into a retirement home completely run and operated by AI assistants.
Understanding our stopping strategies and decision thresholds can help us not only make decisions but prioritize our search for the information we value. Out of 100+ elements of a car like mileage, colour, price, social image, speed, brand, size, etc. our decision likely boils down to less than 10 key attributes that carry much of the decision's weight.
For Ontarians provincially, and Canadians federally, one of the most important decisions we all must make is the upcoming Provincial/Federal elections. Again, it’s a choice with hundreds of factors and variables that may influence our ultimate decision but take a moment to ask yourself what the key variables are for you. Do you like the candidate but not their party? Do you like their policies but not the person? Are you not convinced by any of the options and think you may sit this election out? Political campaigns are floods of compelling information and attempts to undermine competing candidates, but all of the facts and figures aren’t equally influential in your decision.
Don’t get overwhelmed and swept away by the flood of information. Find the anchor points that you value and hold on tight. Everything else has sway but will rush past you if you let it. There are calmer waters coming.
If you want your friends to try this game for themselves, send them the link to this article or download the attachment here for a longer version of the game.